Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts

Sunday, May 04, 2014

Book of Proof by Richard Hammack


For any student who wants to read mathematics at undergraduate level should purchase this book. It is an introduction to mathematical proof and at its present price of approximately £8 is a good buy. I think you can download it free from the authors’ personal webpage.

It has a large number of exercises to reinforce your understanding and some good illustrations.

I do not know who published this book but it lacks a polished output and gives the impression that it has been printed on a local printer and bounded together; maybe this is why it can be sold at such a cheap price. Additionally it only gives solutions to odd numbered questions which can be off putting to a student who wants to use this book for self-learning.

Wednesday, February 01, 2012

Review of The Mathematical Universe by William Dunham


This is a popular mathematics book for the layman. The author has succeeded in writing interesting articles in mathematics which are laid out alphabetically. Dunham discusses the problems and personalities in the history of mathematics. If you want a student hooked into mathematics then this the book they should read.
The technical mathematics in the book are excellently described in simple terms that the average layman can understand. Dunham really does bring mathematics to live in this book.
Initially I was reluctant to purchase a book which is mapped out in alphabetic order. However Dunham managed to make the progression from one chapter to the next seamless. Chapter 1 is on arithmetic and the last chapter called Z is on complex numbers. 
The book is very well organised and has good quality writing style – well expressed, clarity, coherence etc. Dunham has struck the right balance between writing thoroughly and for the amateur or non-professional. Illustrations are sprinkled throughout the book and the author has used these with dramatic effect.
I would recommend this book to any student or teacher of mathematic as well as for non mathematicians.
Kuldeep Singh 
1st Feb 2012

Saturday, December 13, 2008

Yearning For The Impossible by John Stillwell

Review of Yearning For The Impossible by John Stillwell
This is a wonderful book to read around the subject of mathematics. I learned a lot from this book which can be used in general class discussion to motivate students in a particular field of mathematics. There are some real gems in the book such as:
The word surd comes from the Latin surdus meaning deaf.
The product of sum of two squares is itself the sum of two squares.
A simple example of an elliptic function is the height of a point on an ellipse given in terms of the arc length.
Relationship between Gaussian primes and ordinary primes.
Hamilton’s quaternion which is another number system.
3-D symmetry is rare because only 5 regular polyhedra are fully symmetrical.
If 1 was prime then we would not have unique prime factorisation.
27 is the only cube which is 2 more than a square number.
There are many others like this.
However this book is not for the layman because as the author says in his preface ‘many of the ideas are hard and there is no way to soften them’.
The author has made extensive and fantastic use of illustrations to soften the blow and give an intuitive view of the mathematics. In particular the author has made excellent use of diagrams in the chapter on curved space.
I really do like the historical context the author has placed his mathematics. I did not know that the Chinese had approximated π by the fraction 355/113 which is accurate to 6 decimal places. Nor did I know that the Leibniz series was known to Indian mathematician(s) well before it was discovered by Leibniz. However the author does not give the name(s) of the Indian mathematician(s) who had discovered this series.
The chapter on the fourth dimension has an excellent historical context where the author describes Hamilton’s search for the arithmetic of triples, quadruples etc. The author starts by saying that the great Irish mathematician Hamilton (1805 to 1865) was the first to envisage complex numbers as pairs of real numbers. He goes on to describe the addition of pairs as component-wise addition, that is,
(a, b) + (c, d) = (a+c, b+d) and multiplication as (a,b).(c,d) = (ac-bd, ad+bc) . This system with addition and multiplication of ordered pairs defined in this manner satisfies all the rules of ordinary algebra (field) and the absolute value is multiplicative. The author claims that Hamilton tried for 13 years to extend this idea to triples (a, b, c) but failed. From the ashes of triples he revived a definition for quadruples (a, b, c, d) which ensured that the absolute value was multiplicative and all the rules of ordinary algebra was satisfied apart from multiplication being commutative (skew field). Hamilton called the system of quadruples with addition and multiplication the quaternion.
There is a wonderful chapter on the relationship between primes and Gaussian primes. The Gaussian prime is defined as a Gaussian integer which has an absolute value greater than 1 and cannot be factored into Gaussian integers of smaller absolute value. Numbers such as 1+i and 1-i are Gaussian primes but 2 is not because
2=(1+i)(1-i)
3 is Gaussian prime and an ordinary prime. This means that the ordinary primes are not a subset of the Gaussian primes. The author perhaps should have included that an ordinary prime of the form 1 mod 4 can be written as the sum of two squares but this can be factorised into Gaussian primes because a^2+b^2 = (a+bi)(a-bi). Therefore an ordinary prime of the form 1 mod 4 is not a Gaussian prime.
The last chapter is a nice description of the different kinds of infinity and countable sets. There is a really interesting quote in this chapter ‘ Many people believe the continuum hypothesis put Cantor in a mental hospital’.
In general there are some really good statements in the book which can be used to hook students to study mathematics such as –
‘Calculus as we know it today, is perhaps, the most powerful mathematical tool ever developed’.
‘Infinitesimal calculus brought almost the whole physical world within the scope of mathematics’. However I do have a number of minor quibbles.
Sometimes a proposition or theorem is not clearly stated and it is only when you are half way through a proof you realise what is happening.
There are statements which do not relate to mathematical reality such as ‘square root of a half a turn’ which means a rotation though a right angle. How are the two related?
Are they related by the polar or exponential form of a complex number?
There are a number of places where the book jumps from a simple introduction to the more advanced level within a few pages. An example of this is, we are introduced to the idea of a complex number and within 10 pages we are discussing Bezout’s Theorem.
In places I am not to sure what the author means. For example on page 45 the author says ‘complex analysis is known for its regularity and order.’ Clearly complex numbers don’t have order. For example if i>0 then i^2>0 which is false and if i<0>0 again this is false.
In addition there are a couple of typos such as on page 137 should read c1 not c2 in the formula of line 2. On page 169 it says substitute (7.6) in (7.1) but there is no (7.6).
Homepage at http://www.mathsforall.co.uk/

Saturday, November 22, 2008

Review of Basic Linear Algebra by Blyth and Robertson

Review of Basic Linear Algebra by Blyth and Robertson
The book gives a thorough and rigorous treatment of linear algebra which is what a first year student will expect to see on a linear algebra course from a British university.
There are a number of numerical examples which lead nicely to the theory of linear algebra. The authors have hit the right balance between proofs of theorems and techniques to apply such theorems.
The ordering of the chapters is sensible with the first 4 chapters on matrices and linear equations before the more abstract work on vector spaces. The theory and manipulations on eigenvalues and eigenvectors is left towards the end of the book.
A great asset of the book is that it is portable and reasonably cheap at around £16 for students to buy and carry around in lectures and library.
It is also good to see that brief solutions to most problems are at the back of the book.
The only solutions omitted are the assignment problems which the lecturer can set as part of the coursework.
Additionally there are sufficient exercises with good progression and it is good to see a whole chapter devoted to a computer algebra package.
However I have following reservations:
In the introduction to the book it is important to state why linear algebra is critical to the student’s mathematical studies. It should say something like “after calculus the most useful mathematical tool ever developed is linear algebra because it brings the physical world within the scope of mathematics”.
A book on linear algebra should have plenty of illustrations so that the student can envisage what is going on and these illustrations can be used to motivate him or her. This book has a severe lack of diagrams.
More words are required to motivate the student and soften the blow. Each chapter should have an introduction, a list of objectives and a summary. I follow the maxim ‘Tell them, at great length, what you are going to do. Do it, and then tell them what you have done’.
The authors do not write in a way that will appeal to weaker students. It is far too succinct.
The word ‘basic’ in the title is not appropriate for this book. A number of A level students cannot divide 10^(-7) by (1/2x10^4) even with a calculator. I can’t see how students will cope with this book without a serious input by a tutor.
Another issue is that the book is not interactive in any way. It seems to be a one way delivery from the authors to the student. A book like this should include some questions which will make the student think and arouse his/her anxiety. I could not find a single question in the text of the book for the reader. Clearly there are a number of problems for the student to tackle but I am referring to questions such as:
1. Why are matrices important?
2. How can we prove this theorem?
3. What approach are we going to use to solve this problem?
A more serious issue is that once the authors have covered a particular concept they expect the student to fully digest it. This is not my experience of students. I think a particular concept used in chapter 9 which was covered in chapter 2 say, needs to be signposted so that the student knows exactly where the idea was defined earlier in the book.
A less serious issue is that the authors use some very compact and complicated notation. It will difficult for first year students to follow some of this compact notation unless they have seen it before.
The authors use mathematical software, MAPLE 7, but it would have been better to integrate this into each chapter rather than bolt on a chapter at the end. Students will be more confident in using the software if it is used throughout the book.