Friday, June 24, 2016

Profile



Hello,
I teach mathematics at the University of Hertfordshire. To contact me send an email to


k.singh@herts.ac.uk.
My Homepage is at http://mathsforall.co.uk/





Linear Algebra Step by Step:
http://www.oup.co.uk/companion/singh


In general I will be writing articles about mathematics, in particular adding comments to the book "Engineering Mathematics through Applications"

Review of How Big is Infinity? By Tony Crilly

This is genuinely a mathematics book for the layman. There are putatively many books on mathematics for the layman but once you start reading them, they are so specialized that you need to be at least an undergraduate to understand them. This is not so for this book. You will be able to comprehend most of this book with just GCSE mathematics background.
The book has the subtitle ‘The 20 Big Maths Questions’ which refers to the 20 chapters (sections) the book is divided into. Each of these 20 question headings are a good hook for any reader such as ‘What is mathematics for?, Are Statistics lies?, Is mathematics beautiful? Moreover, the content under these questions is pertinent and interesting.
The book is a very incisive and lucid reminiscence of important questions of mathematics. It also includes some history of mathematics and manages to describe the latest work in mathematics research.
My only reservation is that many of the applications and mathematics itself has been discussed in a number of different books over time. However, the book is a good blend of erudition and entertainment.
It doesn’t matter how many times you check, recheck a mathematics book, errors and typos always manage to creep in. Here is list of I picked up:
Page 17; The prize money (for the Poincare conjecture) should be in dollars, not pounds.
Page 58; The last digit in the value of e to six decimal places should be 2 and not 1.
Page 116; we draw in the third paragraph is repeated twice.
Page 122: Solve is misspelt as Sove in the penultimate paragraph.

Page 269; The left-hand side of the infinite series should say π/4 and not π. 

Monday, May 25, 2015

Publishing and the Advancement of Science by Michael Rogers

An Excellent Introduction to Publishing Science books
The author spent over 30 years of his working life being a science editor for various publishing companies. He was the commissioning editor for popular science books as well as science textbooks.
Most of this book describes the authors’ time at Oxford University Press (OUP) but also significantly the work involved in commissioning books such as Selfish Genes by Richard Dawkins and Physical Chemistry by Peter Atkins. Both of these books have achieved enormous sales.
The book under review is not an autobiography but emphasises Rogers working life as an editor. There are some really interesting anecdotes regarding his meetings with various authors and the pressures of publishing companies.
Anyone wanting to write a textbook or popular science book should purchase this as it reveals real insight into publishing such books and how to go about such a task.

Kuldeep Singh 25Th May 2015

Wednesday, April 15, 2015


Love and Math by Edward Frenkel
The author is a professional mathematician and describes what it means to do mathematical research. There are some real gems in this book such as:
Which functions (Euler phi function) are used to encrypt credit card numbers.
Which is larger 2/3 or 3/5 – Most people know that 2 bottles of vodka for 3 people is better than 3 bottles for 5 people.
How we can obtain the Fibonacci sequence from its generating function.
What does a finite field mean.
There is also a good explanation of the Langlands Program.
Very few typos (the only two I picked up were both on page 85 - should be divisible not visible and penultimate paragraph should start with ‘As we’.)
It is really pleasing to see that the author does not shy away from the mathematics in his writing.
However this is not a book for the layman because the mathematics is totally inaccessible to the general audience. This is not a piece of writing for a popular audience as I mistakenly believed it was after reading a review before purchasing. To fully appreciate this book you should at least be an undergraduate in mathematics or physics as it is tough going in places.
Throughout the book the author has highlighted his personal struggles of being Jewish with the regime of the Soviet Union. This is really interesting as I was unaware of how the regime thought of all Jews as opponents, criminals, foes (these are my words). When depicting this the author mentions a number of locations in Russia which he should have illustrated with maps as most of us in the West will not be able to visualize the locations.
Additionally I have a few minor quibbles:
There are a number of terms omitted from the glossary such as invariant, winding number.
Should have explained the term monodromy through illustrations.
The author claims ‘It is customary to exclude 1 from this list” (of primes). I always thought of 1 as neither prime nor composite, just a unit.
I conclude that this is not a book for the layman.

Kuldeep Singh 15th April 2015

Monday, November 10, 2014

The Education of a Mathematician by Philip Davies

This book is different from most other books for the mathematics layman. It is a very tangible and personal journey of the author from the 1930’s to end of the 20 century. In general I found it a very readable book on mathematics as well as mathematics education. There is also philosophy discussions in the book.
The author is a professional mathematician who gives his personal experience and what it means to be a mathematician with his travels to various countries.
The author discuss some really important questions such as the future role of mathematics and it applications. Also he reflects back at how mathematics has affected all of us in the past.
The last chapter describes the authors’ talk at the ‘The International Congress of Mathematicians’ in August 1998 given in Berlin. I really like this chapter with subheading such as Male vs Female Mathematics and Soft Mathematics vs Traditional Mathematics.

My only reservation is that it was hard to follow in places as the author is also a philosopher. 

Thursday, October 30, 2014

Review of Mathematics in Victorian Britain by R. Flood, A. Rice and R. Wilson


This book is divided up into mathematics of various era and geographical locations. It gives a flavour of mathematics and mathematicians not only in Britain but also in the Commonwealth.

Since each chapter is written by a new author I found some of the chapters pretty technical and others very accessible where the emphasis is on the people involved. A glossary might have made the book more accessible on the technical side but it would have to be such a large glossary that the book loses its compactness.

There are some really interesting snippets about mathematicians and their social life. I found the last chapter by Jeremy Gray the most interesting and controversial and will let you read this to find out why.

However I do have one serious reservation – the size of the font is far too small and in general I struggled to read this book. Hence the three stars.

Any serious history of mathematics student should purchase this book as it provides good motivation to the methods and approaches that lie behind the mathematics.

Thursday, July 10, 2014

The Simpsons and their Mathematical Secrets by Simon Singh

Until I read this book I was unaware of the sprinkling of mathematics in the Simpsons.

The book discusses the mathematicians on the writing teams of the Simpsons and Futurama. I must say that I was surprised to learn that most of the writers on these programmes are graduates or postgraduates of mathematics or physics.

It is an excellent book for a layman as all the mathematics is explained in detailed.

My reservation is that the book is a series of detached mathematical stories whose only common theme is that these stories appeared in the Simpsons or Futurama. Also these mathematical stories are so common that if you have read any mathematical popular book you would have come across them. So nothing new here.

However I do think any serious mathematics student should purchase this book as it provides good motivation to study mathematics at undergraduate level.
 


 

Monday, May 05, 2014

I am so proud that the front cover of my book is Mandela Bridge in South Africa.

Sunday, May 04, 2014

Book of Proof by Richard Hammack


For any student who wants to read mathematics at undergraduate level should purchase this book. It is an introduction to mathematical proof and at its present price of approximately £8 is a good buy. I think you can download it free from the authors’ personal webpage.

It has a large number of exercises to reinforce your understanding and some good illustrations.

I do not know who published this book but it lacks a polished output and gives the impression that it has been printed on a local printer and bounded together; maybe this is why it can be sold at such a cheap price. Additionally it only gives solutions to odd numbered questions which can be off putting to a student who wants to use this book for self-learning.

Tuesday, April 02, 2013



How to study for a Mathematics Degree by Lara Alcock



2nd April 2013
This is a book that every potential undergraduate student of mathematics should purchase. It has a very thorough description of what is involved with being an undergraduate in mathematics at university.
Alcock has succeeded in writing a relevant, interesting and beneficial account of what it is like to be a maths undergraduate. She highlights the differences between pure and applicable mathematics and what skills are needed to flourish in these. However the emphasis is on pure mathematics throughout the book.
Additionally the author does not shy away from doing some serious mathematics even though the book is written for the layman. The technical mathematics is described in simple terms that all sixth formers will understand.
The book is very well organised and has good quality writing style – well expressed, clarity, coherence etc. It is split into two – mathematics and study skills.
My only reservation is the lack of illustrations. Including these would have more of an impact but it is not a serious omission.
I would recommend this book to any student or teacher of mathematics.
Kuldeep Singh

Wednesday, February 01, 2012

Review of The Mathematical Universe by William Dunham


This is a popular mathematics book for the layman. The author has succeeded in writing interesting articles in mathematics which are laid out alphabetically. Dunham discusses the problems and personalities in the history of mathematics. If you want a student hooked into mathematics then this the book they should read.
The technical mathematics in the book are excellently described in simple terms that the average layman can understand. Dunham really does bring mathematics to live in this book.
Initially I was reluctant to purchase a book which is mapped out in alphabetic order. However Dunham managed to make the progression from one chapter to the next seamless. Chapter 1 is on arithmetic and the last chapter called Z is on complex numbers. 
The book is very well organised and has good quality writing style – well expressed, clarity, coherence etc. Dunham has struck the right balance between writing thoroughly and for the amateur or non-professional. Illustrations are sprinkled throughout the book and the author has used these with dramatic effect.
I would recommend this book to any student or teacher of mathematic as well as for non mathematicians.
Kuldeep Singh 
1st Feb 2012

Tuesday, December 27, 2011

The Story of Mathematics by Anne Rooney

27 December 2011

This book is full of interesting facts on the history of mathematics such as where our symbols + , – , = and square root originated from. There are also details of mathematics of the 20th Century such as fractals and fuzzy logic. In places the book is fascinating reading such as ‘Pascal’s Triangle is called Khayyam’s Triangle in Iran.’ A student doing mathematics would find this book intriguing and learn some entertaining facts about the history of the subject.

The author has made good use of colour in diagrams but the diagrams are not referenced. There is also no caption for tables.

The layout of some details is rather peculiar. For example page 27 of the book claims that minus sign was first used by Johannes Widmann but does not mention who Widmann is until page 130.

In general the book is full of interesting facts but does lack detail in places. I think it would have been a better book with fewer facts but more details and mathematics about some of these facts.

I personally do not like the text layout in two columns per page. It just doesn’t flow as well as a traditional one column per page book. Additionally it is confusing in places with various diagrams and boxed information on the same page. However I can see the advantage of being a portable book of 208 pages, something that you can fit into your pocket.

Font size of the comprehensive index is rather small with three columns to the page.

Even with these reservations I would recommend this book to any student or layman who is interested in the history of mathematics.

Kuldeep Singh

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Femininity, Mathematics and Science, 1880-1914

This is an excellent account of the history of women in the academic world of mathematics, science and engineering between 1880 and 1914.

Jones focuses on the barriers women faced at the turn of the 19th century such as the scientific laboratory which was seen as a harsh environment for women. These labs were places of manliness and heroism. An example is Cavendish Laboratory at Cambridge which is named after Henry Cavendish who passed electric current through his own body. Even Darwin had theorised that women’s intellect was not on par with men and women were lower down the evolutionary scale, closer to animals. The author also provides an interesting history of the suffragette’s movement.

Jones has concentrated on two particular women, Hertha Ayrton and Grace Young, who both attended Girton College Cambridge to study mathematics. The author states that Hertha was the first Jewish woman to enter Cambridge and that she renounced Judaism so that she could assimilate into the middle class scientific society. Both women took the mathematical tripos examination at Cambridge with Hertha Ayrton opting for the applied mathematics route whilst Grace chose pure mathematics.

The author describes how by the end of the 19th century men were deserting the mathematics tripos for natural sciences tripos which consequently made this masculine in character. However the new women’s colleges (Girton and Newnham) retained their preferences for mathematics.

The author makes a really fascinating point on the use of language in mathematics (something I did not realise) . ‘The feminised language distinguished pure mathematics from the applied and helped women to feel comfortable within the discipline’. Her she is referring to proofs being elegant and theorems - beautiful. Jones gives some really interesting definitions of pure mathematics such as ‘Mathematics is absolute knowledge, permanent and unchanging over time’. The author goes on to say ‘Around 1900 Pure Mathematics prided itself on being uncontaminated by the real world’.

Jones highlights how mathematics was changing by the end of the 19th century. It was moving away from algebraic geometry to a more abstract area such as set theory and Gottingen in Germany led the way. Gottingen was the leading centre for mathematics by the end of the 19th century. Grace Young moved to Gottingen between 1900 and 1908 and became a member of the Gottingen Mathematics Club. By this time it was not unusual to see a small group of women in Gottingen mathematics lectures. However the author highlights some serious impediments on women because there were severe lack of academic openings for women in Germany as well as England.

Grace’s work at Gottingen had an enormous influence on the development of Cambridge mathematics according to the author. Her and her husband were at the forefront of the new mathematical analysis.

Hertha Aryton’s research at Central College London was in arc lights being used for search lights, street lights and other public lighting. When her husband died in 1908 she had no further dealing with Central College London.

Jones states that women encountered fewer obstacles in infiltrating mathematics as it did not necessarily require an institutional base. Hertha required a lab whilst Grace needed pencil, desk and access to a mathematical education.

In general this book is an excellent history of the barriers faced by women in academic circles around the 1900’s. I was not aware of such rich history and there are very few books in this particular field. I particularly liked the rare photographs in the book and would have preferred to have more of these. Also the author has made good use of graphs by highlighting the number of male and female students taking the mathematics and natural sciences triposes. My only gripe would be the cost of the book at £55. I think this book should be within the financial budgets of students.

I only found a couple of typos. On page 40 it should say 1890’s not 1990’s. On page 169 it should say 23 mathematical problems rather than 123 mathematical problems.

Kuldeep Singh

Monday, October 18, 2010

What’s Luck Got to Do with It? By Joseph Mazur

The book is divided into three parts – history, mathematics (probability and statistics) and the psychology of gambling.

Generally speaking this is a well written contemporary book including many interesting facts, such as the term ‘crook’ originates from the crooked dice used by gambling cheats. Another interesting section is the author’s exploration of the significance of the number 7 – the colours of a rainbow, the number of days in a week, the sum of the numbers on opposite sides of a cubical die.

Joseph Mazur gives a very tangible description of the law of large numbers, using the example of the probability of heads being approximately ½ for a large number of throws of a coin. Using the same theme the author highlights examples of the difference between the terms expected value and the mean. There is also an excellent account of the Normal Distribution.

The author gives a good description of the recent international financial crisis and reveals how closely linked Wall Street is with Las Vegas.

Mazur has made good use of illustrations, in particular when explaining possible outcomes of a game like throwing dice (Page 21).

My gripe is that sometimes numerical values are given but it is not made clear where these values have come from. For example on page 136 when referring to the lottery in New Hampshire, the book states ‘The total number of combinations of picking all six numbers is 5,245,786’. Whilst this is correct it would have been helpful to write this number as the combination formula C with superscript 42 and subscript 6 so that the reader knows that you are selecting 6 out of 42.

An issue which might cause problems for the reader is the flow of the text. The book is peppered with callouts which are mathematical justifications of particular statements. These are located at the back of the book with reference in the main text. Hence the reader is continually flicking back and forth. I think these callouts should be in the main text. You can of course choose to ignore these callouts and still understand the general concepts.

While not a serious omission I would like to have seen a callout defining standard deviation, as it is a term used throughout the mathematics section.

The book would have added substantial value if it included answers to popular statistical questions, such as: why car insurance is cheaper for women.

I only found one typo on page 121 where the Greek symbols mu and sigma are missing in the statement before the formula. Additionally this statement should follow after the formula.

Thursday, May 20, 2010

Review of Linear Algebra and its Applications by D.C. Lay

The most obvious benefit of this particular book is its size. At fewer than five hundred pages it is a comparatively light book. Despite its compact nature, it does include some clear and helpful illustrations, and features some interesting applications
However, the layout is far from appealing, and at first glance can be confusing. The answers to the random exercises can be difficult to locate, and the solutions are often too brief to be of any use. In general the proofs are difficult to follow because they are in compact notation, and like many books of this type, it makes little provision for students struggling to remember previously mentioned results and definitions. In some cases a theorem is stated on page X and then the proof of this theorem is given on page X+2 without restating the theorem. This means the reader is constantly flicking between pages X and X+2. The inclusion of repeated theorems would not hamper the confident mathematician, but would be invaluable to a less self assured student.
There seems to be little attempt made to inspire the reader, and its approach is largely clinical and less personal.

Review of Elementary Linear Algebra by Larson and Edwards

This book has an attractive layout, with its theorems and definitions clearly and repetitively presented in highlighted boxes. It is easy to follow and could certainly prove useful to a weak student.
However, many results are stated without providing proof, leaving the student to produce the proof as part of the exercise. Underpinning this type of mathematics with proof is certainly a fundamental part of the education process, but in my experience many students find this an intimidating step. I believe it is vital that students have proofs demonstrated repeatedly, until they become confident enough to formulate their own. This book could undoubtedly benefit from the inclusion of more examples.
In addition, there is a noticeable lack of illustrations, giving the book a very dense feel.
Generally speaking, while this book might provide a valuable handbook for some students, I don’t believe its style engages the attention of the reader and it doesn’t attempt to provide a thorough explanation of linear algebra.

Review of Elementary Linear Algebra by Anton and Rorres

This is a polished, well written text and features a wide variety of interesting contemporary applications towards the end of the book
Its definitions and theorems are highlighted and boxed, and it makes excellent use of illustrations.
However, after their initial introduction, the definitions and results are not reprinted. This makes the book awkward to use and the reader is often forced to search back through the book to find a particular formula or theorem. It is my opinion that the average student is unlikely to absorb this information at their first attempt, and I think it is important to repeat important points until the student is completely familiar with them.
This book also fails to summarise each chapter. My experience of students is that they find a modular approach to mathematics easier to absorb, and I think it is imperative that at the conclusion of each section, new information is condensed and consolidated before the next module commences.
Its explanations are somewhat brief in places, and it uses a compact notation. A confident mathematician would find this method of presentation clear and concise, while the nervous undergraduate finds this kind of brevity difficult to interpret.

Monday, August 24, 2009

Journey through Genius by William Dunham

This book gives a thorough treatment of the history of important mathematical results. There are a number of interesting mathematical examples set in an historical context which makes the book very joyful to read.
The author has hit the right balance between the mathematics such as proofs of theorems and the history behind each theorem. It is good to see the author does not shy away from producing proofs of results which many popular writers tend to eschew so that they can increase their sales. This can be challenging at times for the reader but they can skip these without losing the flow.
Dunham has a fantastic writing style which keeps the reader hooked and intrigued.
Another great asset of the book is that it is portable and reasonably cheap at around £10. I manage to read most of it in Starbucks with pen and paper of course.
However I have following reservations:
Font size is too small and it is particularly difficult to read some of the fractions.
Two typographical errors are – On page 170 the fraction should be 5/128 and not 5/12. On page 238 the factorization should be over 2a and not just a.
On page 235 the first Fermat prime 3 is missing.
A less serious issue is that once the author has covered a particular concept he expects the reader to fully digest it. Dunham has tackled this by signposting his earlier results but I think it would have been more readable for the layman to see the statement of the result again.
This is a book for anybody interested in history of mathematics or mathematics in general. You do not need to be a mathematician to appreciate this book.
Overall I would say this is an excellent book and would recommend anybody interested in mathematics to purchase this.
Kuldeep Singh
24th August 2009

Tuesday, August 04, 2009

Review of ‘Recountings’ by Joel Segel

This is a fascinating history of mathematics at MIT covering the period of post WWII to the present. It gives a detailed account of how mathematics at MIT was converted from a service department for engineers to the high class research department over this period.
This is a book for the layman and also academics who work in such environments. Many mathematics departments throughout the world could do well be investing in this book and emulating a lot of the work done at MIT. The book highlights that the main reason for the transformation was by hiring some of best mathematicians in the world.
The book has a different style to mathematics books for the layman in the sense that it is based on a collection of interviews with 12 members of MIT and the widow of Norman Levison.
The author highlights some well known stories about the men (apart from the first interview which is with Fagi Levison all the other 12 interviews are with men) in mathematics at MIT such as how they were hooked into the institute from other organisations. Additionally the book highlights the arguments within the department between pure and applied mathematicians.
My main reservations regarding the book are:
• It contains no index. This is a serious omission.
• The book does not read well in places and it should have been more thoroughly reviewed.
Generally it was a good joy to read this book and definitely worth buying.
Kuldeep Singh

Monday, July 20, 2009

Review of ‘The Unfinished Game’ by Keith Devlin

I really enjoyed reading this book. It is an excellent account of the history of probability theory. It is essentially a correspondence between the two great French mathematicians, Fermat and Pascal.
The book has an interesting hook with the opening paragraph being a letter sent by Pascal to Fermat. The basis of this correspondence asks ‘how should we divide the stakes if a particular game is incomplete’. This lays the ground work for probability theory.
I liked the style of the author and the way he dipped into some straightforward mathematics in this book.
The history is particularly appealing with the explanation of how Graunt developed his mortality tables. It also goes on to state that Newton’s first great mathematical discovery, the binomial theorem, is based on Pascal’s triangle. Additionally the book explains with entertainment detail the personalities of Fermat and Pascal.
There are also some very fascinating applications of probability mentioned in the book such as how the repeated use of Bayes theorem predicted an attack on the pentagon and also the explanation of why DNA profiling is so reliable.
However the book has the following shortcomings:
It should have stated the dates of birth and death of all the mathematicians mentioned in the book.
On page 83 the author misses the first Fermat prime 3.
The last sentence in the second paragraph on page 102 should say ‘bet 24 to 40, that is 3 to 5, that a sixteen year old will die before the age thirty six’.
This is a book for anybody interested in history of mathematics or mathematics in general. You do not need to be a mathematician to appreciate this book.
Overall I would say this is a very successful book and would recommend anybody interested in mathematics or history of mathematics to purchase this book.